In the world of commercial real estate, location and uniqueness often drive value — and there’s no better example than the recent $11.94 million sale of Gray’s Sunoco, the only gas station on the island of Palm Beach. This record-setting transaction reflects the scarcity and desirability of commercial properties in affluent markets.
A One-of-a-Kind Commercial Asset
Situated at 340 S. County Road, near Palm Beach Town Hall, Gray’s Sunoco has long been more than just a gas station. With its full-service pumps and ability to service high-end vehicles like Rolls-Royces and Ferraris, it serves as both a community staple and a critical service point in times of need — particularly during hurricane season when fuel supplies run low.
The property, which includes four service bays and a small convenience store, sits on just four-tenths of an acre. Yet, its small footprint didn’t stop it from commanding a premium price — a hallmark of high-value commercial real estate in exclusive markets.
From $2.6M to $11.94M in Two Decades
The seller, Peter Berley, acquired the property in 2005 for $2.6 million. After 20 years of ownership, the recent sale represents a nearly fivefold increase in value, reflecting Palm Beach’s booming real estate market and the rising importance of essential-use properties.
The buyer, Alexander Hufty Griswold, is a well-known Palm Beach real estate investor with deep family roots in the area. Through a Delaware-registered LLC linked to his Armata Holdings Management Corp., Griswold secured the property with the intention of maintaining its current use.
Why This Sale Matters
This transaction highlights several key trends in commercial real estate:
• Scarcity Drives Value: As the only gas station in Palm Beach, Gray’s Sunoco offers a rare, irreplaceable service. In markets where land is limited and zoning is strict, unique commercial assets often appreciate faster than traditional properties.
• Community-Centric Investments: Griswold’s commitment to preserving the property as a gas station reflects a growing emphasis on investing with community impact in mind. Essential-use properties that serve local needs can maintain stable demand regardless of market cycles.
• Historical and Emotional Value: The station’s history dates back to the early 20th century, adding sentimental value to its already prime location. Properties with a legacy often command higher prices due to their cultural and historical significance.
What This Means for Commercial Real Estate Investors
The $11.94 million sale is a reminder that not all commercial real estate is created equal. In exclusive markets like Palm Beach, properties that blend necessity, scarcity, and history can achieve exceptional valuations. Investors seeking long-term appreciation should consider essential-use properties in high-demand areas where competition is low but impact is high.
As Palm Beach continues to evolve, the preservation of landmarks like Gray’s Sunoco demonstrates that commercial real estate is about more than just transactions — it’s about sustaining the fabric of the community.
At Cohen Commercial, we understand the value of unique commercial assets. Whether you’re buying, selling, or investing, we’re here to help you navigate the market with confidence.
Cited Source: Palm Beach Daily News, “Palm Beach’s Sole Gas Station, Which Offers Full-Service Pumps, Sells for $11.94M” by Darrell Hofheinz, March 20, 2025.
Lilly Simpson is the Marketing Assistant for Cohen Commercial.